Welcome to Supreme Pizza
Supreme Pizza, located at 27 Boston Post Rd, Waterford, CT, is a beloved local eatery renowned for its delicious takeout offerings. With a menu featuring not just classic pizzas—like the flavorful Green Pepper and Anchovy varieties—but also hearty subs and fresh salads, it caters to a variety of tastes. Customers rave about the generous portions and outstanding sauces that elevate each dish. The family-owned charm is palpable, welcoming guests with friendly service. While the pizza is good, patrons highly recommend trying the substantial grinders and seasonal items. Supreme Pizza is a must-visit for satisfying comfort food.
-
27 Boston Post Rd, Waterford, CT 06385, United States27 Boston Post Rd, Waterford, CT 06385, United States Hotline: +1 860-443-8177
Welcome to Supreme Pizza, a local gem nestled in the heart of Waterford, Connecticut. Located at 27 Boston Post Rd, this establishment has been serving the community for years, renowned for its warm atmosphere and delectable offerings. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty sub, a hearty salad, or a comforting slice of pizza, Supreme Pizza has something for everyone.
When you step inside, you're not just a customer; you're part of a family tradition. Patrons rave about the generous portions and welcoming staff, often taking the time to greet you with a smile. It’s a place where nostalgia meets quality, as many have fond memories from childhood visits that continue to this day.
One standout aspect is the selection of grinders. The Bacon Grinder and Steak Grinder receive glowing reviews, with customers like Peter Ferro calling the spicy Italian sausage sub "one of the best." The rich and flavorful fillings, paired with high-quality bread, ensure that every bite leaves you wanting more. Another crowd favorite is the Tuna Grinder, which not only comes packed with robust flavors but also offers substantial weight, as noted by david Claspell.
If salads are more your speed, the Grilled Chicken Salad is a must-try. Customers love its fresh ingredients and satisfying portions, making it a great choice for those seeking a lighter option without compromising on taste. Moreover, seasonal delights like homemade chili and chicken rice soup keep diners coming back for more.
Of course, no visit to Supreme Pizza would be complete without indulging in their signature pizzas. While some may describe the pizza as a touch "Greeky," the rich sauces and quality ingredients elevate the experience, with exquisitely crafted crusts that leave you savoring every last bite. As Bruce Provencher mentions, the standout element is undoubtedly the sauce, which brings life to every dish, enhancing the overall flavor profile in a way that few places can achieve.
In conclusion, Supreme Pizza is more than just a pizzeria—it's a cherished local eatery that combines family traditions with culinary excellence. With friendly service, a diverse menu, and a commitment to quality, it's easy to understand why people keep returning. So whether you're craving a delicious grinder or a classic pizza, make your way to Supreme Pizza and experience the warmth and flavors they have to offer. You won't be disappointed.
I got the spicy Italian sausage sub, and I tell ya what. That mutha was one of the best sausage subs I've ever had, and I grew up in an Italian area of New Jersey, eating that kinda stuff all the time. This thing is the real deal. Good heat. Everything was delicious. Don't take my word for it, but you'll be missing out. Also, my wife got a tuna, which she loved with pickles...idk that ain't for me, but she enjoyed it. So point is. This place is pretty alright. The pizza is a bit Greeky if ya know what I mean but not bad but not what I'd recommend going to supreme for. Gotta get the Subs!
Tuna grinder literally weighed as much as a small 5 pound weight, tasted excellent, roll was top notch. Mozzarella pizza was very good and rice pudding was on point. Portions were incredibly generous.
I’ve been going to supreme since I was a child. It’s still owned by the same family and the food is phenomenal. I love the grilled chicken salad and the Italian grinder. Those are my favorites. they always welcome you in with a big hello and everyone is always very friendly. Take out only.
Every single item of food I have ever ordered from Supreme Pizza has been 100% delicious! I don't know how they can make a simple Ham grinder taste like the best Ham grinder I've ever had, but they do. The pizza is all good, in fact so good that you want it all, including every inch of the crust. Not on the menu are some delicious seasonal items like their chili and chicken rice soup (my fav) and American Goulash, all homemade, all delicious.
This is a takeout review. All food is eaten promptly in the vehicle. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and a meatball grinder. What really stood out here was the sauce. Both items had outstanding flavor due to the sauce. Very good meatballs and loaded with food feedings the grinder. Nice crust and ample cheese on the pizza. And really nice people inside. On a scale from 0-10 I would rate this 8.5.
The food is amazing and always just the way you ordered it. I have never been disappointed! Through the years when I had volunteered at sporting events Supreme was so generous helping out with food. Amazing Family that loves our community. You walk in and you are greeted with smiles that make you feel like family.
We ate here regularly 20 years ago before we moved. We came back to the area to show our son where he was born and this was our first stop. The food, service, and atmosphere were even better than we remembered.
I relocated to the area from Oklahoma City and let me tell you this, I’ve never been disappointed and the pizza here is amazing. Enjoyed the friendly convo from the owner and my pizza was hot and fresh. I ordered a large cheese and small beef pizza. Walked in and ordered and waited, the wait wasn’t long either. Appreciated the owner opening the box and showing me my pizza before walking away. I’ll be back.